Wayne Rooney expressed strong disapproval of Nuno Espirito Santo’s decision to rest key players during Nottingham Forest’s FA Cup quarter-final match against Brighton.
The former Manchester United and England captain stated that he would have been “fuming” if he were a Forest fan, considering the magnitude of the fixture.
Despite Espirito Santo’s tactical choices, Nottingham Forest secured their place in the semi-finals after a nerve-wracking penalty shootout victory.
The match remained goalless through 120 minutes before Forest triumphed from the spot.
However, questions arose over the decision to delay the introduction of Anthony Elanga and Callum Hudson-Odoi until the 61st minute.
Controversial Team Selection Sparks Debate
Nottingham Forest faced a significant setback in the build-up to the match, with top scorer Chris Wood ruled out due to a hip injury.
As expected, Taiwo Awoniyi stepped up to lead the attack, but Espirito Santo made a surprise move by benching both Elanga and Hudson-Odoi.
Instead, he opted for Ryan Yates and Danilo in the starting lineup, making three changes from the team that previously defeated Ipswich.
Both Elanga and Hudson-Odoi have played instrumental roles in Forest’s campaign, making their omission from the starting XI a puzzling choice.
Espirito Santo’s cautious approach was likely influenced by Forest’s ambitions in the Premier League, where they are pushing for a Champions League spot. The club is set to return to league action against Manchester United just days after their FA Cup triumph.
Read Also: Transfer Gossip Today: Darwin Nunez Likely to Leave Liverpool, Nottingham Forest and Newcastle Interested
Rooney’s Strong Reaction
Rooney did not hold back in his criticism of Espirito Santo’s lineup, questioning the decision on BBC’s pre-match coverage.
“I’m shocked,” Rooney admitted. “The FA Cup is such a prestigious tournament, and to rest players in a quarter-final when you have a great opportunity to reach the semi-finals…
I don’t understand it. They’re aiming for Champions League football, which is great, but as a player, you want to maintain momentum and keep winning games.”
He further added, “To leave key players out when the game is not guaranteed on Tuesday is beyond belief for me.
If I were a fan, I’d be absolutely fuming. Winning silverware should be a priority, and this was a fantastic opportunity.”
Espirito Santo Defends His Strategy
Despite widespread criticism, Espirito Santo stood by his decision, highlighting the importance of squad rotation.
“The FA Cup provides opportunities for players who work hard and don’t always get Premier League minutes,” the Forest head coach explained in his pre-match interview.
“Taiwo [Awoniyi] has been training well, and Danilo has earned his chance. It’s about rewarding players who deserve their moments.”
When asked about balancing Forest’s cup and league commitments, he emphasized a game-by-game approach. “Today was a tough match, and now we focus on the next one.”
Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler Not Surprised
Brighton’s head coach, Fabian Hurzeler, was not taken aback by Espirito Santo’s team selection. He pointed out that Forest had previously adopted similar defensive strategies against top teams.
“They’ve played like this against big teams like Chelsea and Liverpool,” Hurzeler observed.
“A defensive shape, waiting for transition opportunities. Regardless of whether Elanga or Hudson-Odoi play, they are effective on the counter. They also focus heavily on set-pieces, so we had to be alert in all phases of the game.”
Forest’s Gamble Pays Off—But Was It Worth It?
Despite the controversy, Forest’s strategy ultimately delivered a positive outcome, securing a semi-final berth.
However, the debate remains was resting key players a wise decision, or did the team narrowly escape the consequences of an overly cautious approach?
With crucial Premier League fixtures ahead, including a tough clash against Manchester United, only time will tell if Espirito Santo’s tactical gamble benefits Forest in their quest for both domestic and European success.
For now, fans will celebrate their FA Cup progression, but Rooney’s concerns echo the sentiments of many who believe that silverware opportunities should never be taken lightly.
