Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has delivered a scathing assessment of the current squad, naming eight players he believes the club should part ways with.
Lisandro Martinez Among Scholes’ Controversial Picks
Despite being a standout performer since joining Manchester United under Erik ten Hag, Argentine center-back Lisandro Martinez finds himself on Scholes’ “must-sell” list.
While many fans regard Martinez as one of the team’s most reliable players, Scholes remains unconvinced about his long-term fit at the club.
Other Notable Names on the List
Scholes also singled out Dutch defender Matthijs de Ligt, who only joined United last summer, and forward Joshua Zirkzee, a fellow summer signing who has struggled to make an impact since arriving from Bologna.
Three England internationals—Marcus Rashford, Mason Mount, and Luke Shaw—also made the list. Rashford, who recently reconsidered his future at the club after a period of limited game time under head coach Ruben Amorim, is one of the more surprising inclusions.
Meanwhile, Brazilian duo Casemiro and Antony round out Scholes’ eight-player list, with the former midfielder questioning their value to the team’s ongoing rebuild.
Also See: Amad Diallo Signs Long-Term Contract With Manchester United Until 2030
Scholes on Alejandro Garnacho: A Potential Departure?
In addition to naming eight players United should sell, Scholes discussed the potential sale of Alejandro Garnacho. While he acknowledged Garnacho’s potential, Scholes expressed doubts about the young winger’s consistency and decision-making.
“I wouldn’t be afraid or worried if they sold Garnacho,” Scholes told TNT Sports.
“He’s capable, no doubt about that, but finding his position in this team has been a struggle.”
However, Scholes was adamant about the importance of keeping other young talents, such as Kobbie Mainoo, in the squad.
Paul Scholes’ Full ‘Sell List’
1. Lisandro Martinez
2. Matthijs de Ligt
3. Joshua Zirkzee
4. Luke Shaw
5. Mason Mount
7. Antony
8. Casemiro
As United fans digest Scholes’ brutal assessment, it remains to be seen whether the club will take his suggestions into account during their rebuild under Ruben Amorim.
Conclusion
Scholes’ criticism highlights the growing pressure on Manchester United to address inconsistencies and improve squad depth.
Whether or not the club acts on his recommendations, it’s clear significant changes are needed to restore United to their former glory.
